Discover the Best Reel Mower for Your Lawn: A Comprehensive Guide

Maintaining a lush, healthy lawn doesn’t have to involve noisy motors, messy fuel, or complicated maintenance routines. Enter the reel mower – an eco-friendly, low-maintenance solution that’s gaining popularity among homeowners seeking a more sustainable way to care for their lawns. But with countless options available, how do you choose the right one for your yard? This guide is here to help. From understanding the key features of reel mowers to exploring the top-rated models on the market, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to make an informed decision. Whether you’re prioritizing affordability, performance, or ease of use, this comprehensive guide will equip you with the insights you need to find the perfect reel mower for your needs.

What is a Reel Mower and How Does it Work?

A reel mower is a manual lawn mower that cuts grass using a set of rotating blades in a cylindrical reel. Unlike gas or electric mowers, the blades on a reel mower work by spinning vertically as you push the mower, slicing the grass cleanly like a pair of scissors. This method of cutting is more precise and healthier for the grass compared to tearing, which can occur with other mower types. Reel mowers are quiet, eco-friendly, and simple to maintain, making them a popular choice for smaller lawns and environmentally conscious homeowners.

Understanding the Blade Mechanism of a Reel Mower

The blade mechanism of a reel mower operates on a scissor-like cutting principle, combining precision and efficiency. The design features a rotating cylinder equipped with multiple curved blades—typically five to seven—that spin vertically. These blades pass closely against a fixed horizontal cutting bar at the base, known as the bedknife. The close proximity between the blades and the bedknife ensures a clean and even cut, slicing grass rather than tearing it, which promotes healthier and more resilient lawns.

One key feature of reel mowers is their ability to adjust the blade height to suit different grass types and conditions. Studies show that maintaining grass at an optimal height, often ranging from 2 to 4 inches depending on the species, can foster stronger root systems and improve resistance to pests and diseases.

Modern reel mowers have evolved with advanced materials and engineering. For example, high-grade steel is commonly used for the blades to maintain sharpness longer, thereby reducing the need for frequent sharpening. Some high-end models integrate self-sharpening technology or include precision-ground blades for enhanced performance.

Another benefit of reel mowers is their eco-friendly operation. Research highlights that traditional gas-powered mowers can emit significant pollutants—up to 11 times more per hour than a typical car. By comparison, reel mowers have zero emissions and require no fuel or electricity, demonstrating their sustainability. Additionally, their quiet operation reduces noise pollution, enhancing the mowing experience for users and their neighbors alike.

By understanding the mechanics and advantages of reel mowers, it becomes easier to appreciate their role in promoting healthier lawns while aligning with sustainable practices. Whether for a small suburban yard or a meticulously kept garden, reel mowers continue to offer an effective and environmentally conscious solution.

How Reel Mowers Differ From Rotary Mowers

Reel mowers and rotary mowers operate on fundamentally different cutting mechanisms, each with its own set of advantages and ideal applications. Reel mowers use a scissor-like action with their cylindrical set of blades to shear grass. This method provides a precise, clean cut that promotes grass health by minimizing tearing and reducing stress on the turf. Rotary mowers, on the other hand, feature a horizontally spinning blade that chops grass through impact. While effective for uneven or overgrown lawns, the cutting technique of rotary mowers often results in a rougher finish, which can leave grass susceptible to diseases.

Another key difference lies in their environmental impact. Reel mowers, especially manual ones, are inherently eco-friendly as they operate without fuel or electricity. This absence of energy consumption eliminates carbon emissions entirely, offering a sustainable alternative for lawn care. Conversely, gas-powered rotary mowers produce significant emissions, with studies highlighting that a gas lawn mower can emit as much pollution in an hour as driving a car for 100 miles. For electric rotary mowers, while emissions are reduced, they still depend on electricity sourced from power grids, which may involve fossil fuels.

Furthermore, maintenance and usability stand apart between the two types. Reel mowers excel in low-maintenance requirements due to their straightforward build. Modern reel mowers are lightweight and easy to maneuver, making them well-suited for small to medium-sized lawns. Rotary mowers, with their motorized operation, typically handle larger, rugged areas better but involve higher maintenance needs, including frequent sharpening of the blade and engine upkeep for gas-powered varieties.

Overall, the choice between reel and rotary mowers depends on individual needs, lawn size, and commitment to sustainability. For those prioritizing precision, noise reduction, and environmental mindfulness, reel mowers stand as an excellent option, while rotary mowers may appeal to users tackling larger or tougher terrains.

Benefits of Using a Manual Reel Mower

1. Environmentally Friendly

Manual reel mowers produce zero emissions, making them a sustainable choice for eco-conscious homeowners. Unlike gas-powered mowers, they do not release harmful pollutants into the atmosphere, contributing to cleaner air.

2. Quiet Operation

Reel mowers operate silently, eliminating the noise pollution commonly associated with gas or electric mowers. This makes them ideal for early morning or evening use without disturbing neighbors or family members.

3. Healthier Grass Cuts

The scissor-like cutting action of a reel mower results in cleaner, healthier cuts compared to the tearing action of rotary blades. This reduces stress on the grass, promoting thicker, greener lawns and minimizing susceptibility to disease.

4. Cost-Effective

Operating a manual reel mower eliminates the need for fuel, electricity, or expensive engine repairs, significantly reducing ongoing maintenance costs over time. Beyond the initial purchase, they are a highly economical option.

5. Low Maintenance

Reel mowers require minimal upkeep. Occasional blade sharpening and general cleaning are sufficient to keep them functional for years. Their simple, mechanical design ensures durability and reliability.

6. Physical Exercise

Using a manual reel mower provides a low-impact workout, engaging the user in light cardiovascular activity while maintaining their lawn. It’s an excellent way to stay active and combine fitness with household chores.

7. Compact and Lightweight

Most reel mowers are compact, lightweight, and easy to maneuver. Their simple design allows for effective use in small spaces, narrow pathways, and intricate landscaping areas. They are also easier to store compared to bulky gas-powered models.

8. Safe to Use

Manual reel mowers operate without rotating engines or electrical components, making them safer, especially for households with children or pets. The absence of high-speed spinning blades reduces the risk of accidents.

By combining efficiency, sustainability, and practicality, manual reel mowers remain a timeless tool for achieving a well-maintained, healthy lawn.

How to Choose a Reel Mower for Your Lawn?

When choosing a reel mower for your lawn, consider the following key factors:

1. Lawn Size

Reel mowers are ideal for small to medium-sized lawns. For larger areas, ensure the mower’s cutting width is sufficient to reduce the number of passes needed.

2. Grass Type

Some grasses, like Bermuda or St. Augustine, require sharper, more durable blades. Choose a model suited to the specific grass variety in your yard.

3. Adjustable Cutting Height

Opt for a reel mower with adjustable cutting heights to maintain the ideal grass length for a healthier lawn.

4. Ease of Use

Look for features like comfortable handles, lightweight design, and smooth rolling for effortless operation.

5. Durability and Maintenance

Select a mower with high-quality materials and blades for long-term use. Regular sharpening will keep the blades efficient and effective.

Taking these elements into account will help you find a reel mower that fits your lawn care needs perfectly.

Factors to Consider: Grass Type and Lawn Size

When selecting a reel mower, it’s essential to evaluate the specific grass type and the size of your lawn as these factors can significantly influence your mowing experience and results. Different types of grass, such as Bermuda, Zoysia, and Kentucky Bluegrass, vary in texture, thickness, and growth patterns, requiring blades that can accommodate their unique characteristics. For instance, tougher grass types like Bermuda benefit from reel mowers with more blades (typically 7-10), as these provide a cleaner cut for dense or low-growing grasses. Conversely, softer grasses like Fescue may perform well with fewer blades.

Lawn size dictates the necessary width and weight of a reel mower. Small to medium lawns (under 5,000 square feet) are ideal for reel mowers with cutting widths between 14-20 inches, balancing maneuverability and efficiency. For larger lawns, consider wider reel mowers that cover more ground in less time, though they may be slightly heavier to push. By aligning your equipment choice with your grass type and lawn dimensions, you optimize efficiency and consistency in upkeep, ensuring a healthier and aesthetically pleasing lawn.

Comparing American Lawn Mower and Other Brands

American Lawn Mower excels in eco-friendliness and simplicity, while other brands like Toro and Ego offer advanced features, power, and versatility.

Parameter	American Lawn Mower	Toro	Ego
Power	Manual	Gas/Electric	Electric
Eco-Friendliness	High	Moderate	High
Ease of Use	Moderate	High	High
Maintenance	Low	Moderate	Low
Cost	Low	Moderate	High
Best For	Small lawns	Versatility	Quiet, large lawns

Understanding Blade Height Adjustment and Mower Settings

Blade height adjustment is a crucial feature in lawn care as it directly impacts the health and appearance of your grass. Most modern reel mowers come with adjustable blade heights ranging from 0.5 inches to over 3 inches, catering to various grass types and seasonal needs. For example, warm-season grasses like Bermuda or Zoysia thrive at shorter heights, typically between 0.5 to 1.5 inches, while cool-season grasses such as Fescue or Kentucky Bluegrass require slightly higher cuts, around 2 to 3 inches.

Adjustable mower settings also allow homeowners to adapt their mowing routines to changing weather conditions and growth patterns. During periods of rapid spring growth, higher blade settings can prevent scalping and reduce stress on the grass. Conversely, lowering the blade can encourage dense growth in late summer, provided the lawn is healthy and well-watered.

Data shows optimal mowing height contributes to better moisture retention, reduced weed growth, and improved root systems. For example, maintaining the proper grass height can decrease water evaporation by up to 30%, reducing irrigation needs. Taking the time to understand and optimize your blade height adjustments ensures a vibrant and resilient lawn throughout the season.

What are the Top Reel Mower Features to Look For?

When choosing a reel mower, focus on these key features to ensure optimal performance:

1. Adjustable Cutting Height – Allows you to customize the grass height to suit your lawn’s needs and seasonal requirements.
2. Blade Quality and Durability – Look for heat-treated, high-quality steel blades for longer-lasting sharpness and precision cuts.
3. Cutting Width – A wider cutting width covers more ground, reducing mowing time, while narrower designs are ideal for tight spaces.
4. Ease of Maneuverability – Lightweight designs and ergonomic handles make pushing easier, especially on uneven terrain.
5. Low Maintenance Design – Mowers with rust-resistant components and minimal part requirements save time on upkeep.
6. Quiet and Eco-Friendly Operation – Reel mowers are naturally noise-free and powered manually, making them an environmentally responsible choice.

By prioritizing these features, you can choose a reel mower that delivers efficient, clean, and hassle-free lawn care.

Exploring the Benefits of Scissor-like Cutting Action

The scissor-like cutting action of modern reel mowers is renowned for its precision and environmental advantages. Unlike rotary mowers that can tear through grass blades, this method slices cleanly through each blade of grass, reducing stress and promoting healthier growth. Studies show that clean cuts help retain moisture within the grass, improving drought tolerance and overall lawn resilience.

Additionally, reel mower blades operate at lower speeds without relying on fuel or electricity, drastically reducing emissions and energy consumption. According to environmental assessments, reel mowers outperform gas-powered alternatives in eco-friendliness, producing zero greenhouse gases during operation. This makes them an excellent choice for homeowners seeking sustainable lawn care practices.

The efficiency of scissor-like cutting mechanics also contributes to the long-term health of a lawn by minimizing the risk of fungal infections and browning, which are often caused by the jagged edges left by less precise mowers. By investing in a reel mower with high-quality blades and optimal design, users benefit from a lush, greener lawn while maintaining environmental integrity.

The Importance of Ease of Use in a Push Reel Mower

Ease of use is a critical factor when selecting a push reel mower, as it directly influences the mowing experience and overall satisfaction. Modern advancements in design and engineering have contributed to lighter, more ergonomic mowers that require minimal effort to operate. For instance, enhanced blade technology, combined with improved wheel designs, allows for smoother rolling even on uneven terrain, reducing strain on the user.

Additionally, many contemporary models feature adjustable cutting heights, providing flexibility to accommodate various grass types and seasonal growth patterns. Studies suggest that push reel mowers with an average weight of 20-30 pounds are the most manageable for homeowners, balancing stability with maneuverability. Furthermore, the integration of comfort features like cushioned handles or adjustable grips minimizes hand fatigue during longer mowing sessions.

By considering these ease-of-use factors, push reel mowers have become an attractive option for homeowners seeking eco-friendly lawn maintenance without compromising convenience or efficiency.

Evaluating the Durability of Reel Mowers

Durability is a crucial factor when selecting a reel mower, as it directly impacts its lifespan and performance. High-quality reel mowers are often constructed with robust materials such as heat-treated steel for the blades and reinforced alloys for the frame. These materials resist rust and wear, even with regular use on challenging terrain or dense grass types. Studies suggest that well-maintained reel mowers can last 10-15 years or longer, delivering consistent performance across seasons.

The cutting blades are particularly noteworthy in assessing durability. Most reel mowers feature blades designed to retain a sharp edge for extended periods, reducing the frequency of sharpening required. For example, many modern models boast blade sharpening intervals of up to 5-8 years under normal mowing conditions, thanks to precision engineering and advanced materials.

Additionally, the simplicity of the reel mower’s mechanical design plays a pivotal role in its durability. With fewer moving parts compared to gas or electric mowers, the likelihood of mechanical failure decreases significantly, making them both reliable and easier to maintain. Models with sealed ball bearings and sturdy wheel constructions are especially durable, as they withstand wear from repeated movement over uneven surfaces.

Overall, investing in a reel mower constructed with durable components not only ensures a longer product lifespan but also reduces maintenance costs over time, making it a sustainable and economical choice for homeowners.

How to Properly Maintain Your Reel Mower?

1. Clean After Each Use

Remove grass clippings, dirt, and debris from the blades and wheels using a brush or damp cloth. Keeping the mower clean prevents buildup and ensures smooth operation.

2. Sharpen the Blades Regularly

Check the sharpness of the blades at least once a year. Dull blades can tear grass rather than cutting it, affecting both your lawn’s health and the mower’s performance. Use a reel mower sharpening kit for accurate results.

3. Lubricate Moving Parts

Apply a light oil to the blades, wheels, and other moving parts to reduce friction and prevent rust. This helps the mower perform efficiently over time.

4. Inspect and Tighten Bolts

Periodically check all bolts and screws to ensure they remain secure. Tight connections are essential for safe and effective operation.

5. Store in a Dry Location

Keep the mower in a sheltered area to protect it from moisture and harsh weather conditions, which can lead to rust and damage.

Following these steps will keep your reel mower functioning at its best and prolong its lifespan.

Tips for Sharpening the Blades of a Reel Mower

Use a Sharpening Kit

Purchase a reel mower sharpening kit, which typically includes a sharpening compound, application brush, and hand crank. These kits are specifically designed to restore the cutting efficiency of reel mower blades.

Clean the Blades Thoroughly

Before sharpening, clean the blades with a brush or cloth to remove dirt, grass, and debris. This ensures that the sharpening process is effective and prevents particles from interfering with the sharpening compound.

Apply Sharpening Compound

Evenly coat the cutting edges of the blades with the sharpening compound using the brush provided in the kit. This abrasive compound is key to grinding and restoring the sharp edge.

Rotate the Blades Backward

Attach the hand crank to the reel mower and rotate the blades backward. This action allows the sharpening compound to make consistent contact across the entire blade edge, honing them to precision.

Test the Sharpness with Paper

Once the blades have been sharpened, test the sharpness by cutting a piece of paper. If the blades cut cleanly and evenly, the sharpening process is complete. Otherwise, repeat the sharpening steps.

Remove Residual Compound

After sharpening, wipe off any remaining compound with a clean cloth. This prevents residue buildup from affecting the mower’s performance during use.

Check Blade Alignment

Inspect the blades to ensure they are properly aligned, as misalignment can reduce cutting efficiency. Adjust the blade alignment according to the manufacturer’s instructions if necessary.

Regular sharpening, combined with proper maintenance, will enhance the cutting performance of your reel mower and keep your lawn looking immaculate.

Regular Cleaning and Storage Practices

Proper cleaning and storage of your reel mower are essential for extending its lifespan and ensuring peak performance. Here are some detailed practices to help maintain your equipment:

1. Thorough Cleaning After Use

After each mowing session, clean the mower to remove grass clippings, dirt, and debris that can accumulate on the blades and wheels. Use a stiff brush or a hose for this task, ensuring that no residue is left behind. Clean components reduce the risk of rust formation, which can weaken the mower over time.

2. Dry All Parts Completely

Moisture is one of the leading causes of rust and corrosion in gardening tools. After cleaning the mower, wipe all metal parts dry with a lint-free cloth. For added protection, consider applying a light coat of lubrication to the blades and moving parts to prevent water damage.

3. Inspect for Wear and Tear

Regularly examine the mower for any signs of wear, such as loose screws, worn blades, or damaged wheels. Addressing these issues promptly increases the mower’s efficiency and prevents further damage that could escalate into costly repairs.

4. Sharpen Blades Before Storage

Dull blades can stress the mower and inhibit its capacity to cut grass effectively. Sharpening the blades before storing the mower ensures that it is ready for flawless performance in the next mowing season.

5. Store in a Dry, Secure Location

Environmental conditions can significantly impact the condition of your reel mower. Always store the mower in a cool, dry location away from direct sunlight and excessive humidity. If possible, use a protective cover to shield it from dust and other potential contaminants.

6. Seasonal Maintenance Tips

At the end of the mowing season, conduct a comprehensive checkup. Tighten any loose bolts, lubricate all moving parts, and review the manual for specific care instructions tailored to your mower model. This approach ensures that your mower remains in excellent condition throughout its downtime.

By adhering to these cleaning and storage practices, you can prolong the life of your reel mower, maintain its efficiency, and enjoy consistently well-manicured lawns. The effort you invest in maintenance today will save you time and costs in the long run.

Dealing with Thick Grass and Challenging Lawn Conditions

Thick grass and challenging lawn conditions can pose difficulties for reel mowers, but with the right techniques and preparation, you can manage them effectively. First, ensure your mower blades are sharp, as dull blades struggle with dense or overgrown grass and may tear it instead of producing clean cuts. Sharpen your blades regularly, particularly before tackling tougher patches.

For optimal results, mow dense grass in stages rather than attempting to cut it all at once. Set your mower to a higher cutting height for the first pass, then gradually lower it for subsequent passes. This method reduces strain on your mower and minimizes the risk of uneven cutting. Additionally, mow when the grass is dry; wet grass can be heavy and more difficult to cut, often clumping and clogging the mower.

Use consistent mowing patterns to avoid matting the grass. If your lawn has varying thickness levels, approach the denser areas at a slightly slower pace, as this allows the mower to process the extra material more effectively. For longer or thicker grass, consider trimming with a string trimmer or scythe before using the reel mower to simplify your work.

According to contemporary recommendations, keeping grass at a height of about 2.5–4 inches generally strikes a good balance between encouraging lawn health and making mowing manageable. Furthermore, regular maintenance practices like aeration, fertilization, and appropriate watering can alleviate challenging conditions over time, ensuring thicker grass is easier to manage.

By combining these strategies, you can tackle thick grass or uneven terrain effectively and maintain a visually appealing, healthy lawn.

Is a Push Reel Lawn Mower Suitable for You?

A push reel lawn mower works best on small, flat lawns that are well-maintained and trimmed. It has the advantages of being economical and environmental as it doesn’t require gas or electricity and is quieter than its electric counterparts. It will not work well, however, for larger yards, rough uneven land, or thick, overgrown grass as these will make mowing more difficult. Consider your lawn’s size and type along with personal preferences before deciding if a push reel mower is the best fit for your needs.

Pros and Cons of Using a Push Reel Mower

From my experience, push reel mowers are incredibly eco-friendly since they don’t rely on gas or electricity, which also helps keep costs down. They’re quiet, which makes mowing more pleasant and allows me to maintain my lawn without disturbing neighbors. Plus, they’re easy to maintain, with no complex engine parts or fuel to worry about.

On the flip side, I’ve found they’re not ideal for large lawns or uneven terrain, as they require more effort to push in such conditions. They can also struggle with thick or overgrown grass, which can make the task time-consuming and physically demanding. For me, it really depends on the lawn size and condition to determine if this is the best tool.

Comparing Gas, Electric, and Manual Options

Gas tools are powerful and long-lasting but noisy and high-maintenance, electric tools are eco-friendly and quiet but have limited runtime, and manual tools are cost-effective but labor-intensive.

Parameter	Gas	Electric	Manual
Power	High	Moderate	Low
Runtime	Unlimited	Limited	Unlimited
Noise	High	Low	None
Eco-Friendliness	Low	High	High
Maintenance	High	Low	None
Cost	High	Moderate	Low
Ease of Use	Moderate	High	Low

Understanding the Mowing Experience with a Reel Mower

When using a reel mower, I find the experience to be both rewarding and straightforward, but it does come with its quirks. The quiet operation and lack of emissions make it feel environmentally friendly and peaceful, which I really appreciate. However, it’s definitely more physically engaging than using gas or electric options, especially on tougher patches of grass or uneven areas. For me, the satisfaction lies in the simplicity and the sense of accomplishment, but it works best when the lawn is well-maintained and not overly large.

Reference Sources

1. Oregon State University: Choose a lawn mower to fit your needs – Discusses reel mowers and their suitability for specific lawn types.

2. University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources: Healthy Lawns—Mowing: Reel mowers – Provides insights into the benefits and best uses of reel mowers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: What makes the best reel mower for a small lawn?

A: The best reel mower for a small lawn is typically lightweight, easy to maneuver, and has sharp blades to ensure clean cuts. Brands like Scotts and Fiskars offer easy-to-push reel mowers that are perfect for small spaces.

Q: How do reel mowers compare to gas mowers for lawn care?

A: Reel mowers are quieter, eco-friendly, and require less maintenance compared to gas mowers. They are ideal for small lawns and provide a scissor-like cut that promotes healthier grass growth.

Q: Are electric reel mowers suitable for tall grass?

A: While electric reel mowers can handle moderately tall grass, they perform best on shorter lawns. For excessively tall grass, initial mowing with a gas or electric lawn mower may be necessary before using a reel mower.

Q: What are the benefits of using a Fiskars StaySharp reel mower?

A: The Fiskars StaySharp reel mower features a unique cutting system that reduces friction, making it easier to push. It also stays sharper longer than traditional blades, providing an efficient and precise cut.

Q: How does the American Lawn Mower Company’s reel push mower stand out?

A: The American Lawn Mower Company offers durable and reliable reel push mowers that are easy to use and maintain. Their mowers are built to last and deliver a clean, precise cut without the noise and fumes of gas mowers.

Q: Can a 16-inch reel mower handle a large lawn?

A: A 16-inch reel mower is generally more suited for small to medium-sized lawns. For larger lawns, you may need a wider mower or be prepared for more time-consuming mowing sessions.

Q: What type of mower is best for environmentally conscious lawn care?

A: Reel mowers are the best choice for environmentally conscious lawn care as they don’t use gas or electricity, reducing emissions and pollution. They also promote healthier lawns by providing a clean cut.

Q: Is it harder to push a reel mower compared to other types?

A: Reel mowers can be harder to push, especially in tall or thick grass. However, models like the Fiskars StaySharp are designed to minimize effort, making them easier to use compared to traditional reel mowers.

Q: What is the advantage of using a grass catcher with a reel mower?

A: A grass catcher collects clippings as you mow, keeping your lawn tidy and reducing the need for raking. It’s a convenient addition for those looking to maintain a neat appearance without extra work.

Q: How do Earthwise reel mowers differ from other brands?

A: Earthwise reel mowers are known for their affordability and ease of use. They offer models that are lightweight and designed for straightforward assembly and operation, providing a good balance between cost and performance.